Tax update
Council of State, Case No. 28267 of 2026: Intercompany Services Must Be Proven With Their Deliverables, and Payments to the Head Office for Administration or Management Are Deductible Only With Withholding Tax
The Council of State requires intercompany services to be proven with their deliverables and reiterates that payments to the head office for administration or management are deductible only if withholding tax was applied, even where transfer pricing rules are met.
We are sharing a summary of the ruling of February 12, 2026 (Case No. 25000-23-37-000-2020-00319-00 (28267)), in which the Fourth Section of the Council of State upheld the disallowance of deductions for payments to foreign related parties in the 2015 income tax and CREE returns of a Colombian company.
The decision is relevant for subsidiaries, affiliates and branches of foreign companies that pay for services to their group. It clarifies what evidence is required to consider an intercompany service as rendered and reiterates that payments to the head office for administration or management are deductible only if withholding tax was applied, even if the transaction complies with the transfer pricing regime.
What you should know
What did the Council of State decide?
- Services from a related party in Chile: it upheld the disallowance of COP 1,644,783,000 for finance, marketing, customer service, human resources and accounting services, because their actual rendering in 2015 was not proven.
- Services from the head office in the United States: it upheld the disallowance of COP 81,680,000 for administration services, because no withholding tax was applied.
- Inaccuracy penalty: it was maintained on both disallowances.
How is it proven that an intercompany service was actually rendered?
- The contract sets the evidence: the contract with the related party provided that each service would materialize in a report, email, document or other medium according to its nature. For that reason, the Chamber required those deliverables to prove that the service was real.
- Deliverables, not supporting documents: emails, internal working papers, internal corporate analyses, out-of-court statements, job description manuals and payroll, export invoices and the intercompany contracts themselves were not sufficient, since none of them made it possible to identify a deliverable that materialized the obligations under the contract.
- Evidence tied to the tax year: the supporting documents must make it possible to identify the services rendered in the period under review.
- Documents in another language: accounting documents with headings and descriptions in English were not weighed as evidence because they lacked an official translation (art. 251 of the General Procedural Code).
When is a payment to the head office for administration expenses deductible?
- Rule of article 124 of the Tax Code (ET): subsidiaries, branches, affiliates or agencies in Colombia of foreign companies may deduct amounts paid to their head offices or offices abroad for administration or management expenses, provided that withholding tax is applied to those payments.
- No withholding, no deduction: reiterating its case law, the Chamber stated that only payments for administration to the head office that are subject to withholding, that is, those from Colombian sources, are deductible. If there is no withholding, the expense is not deductible.
- Transfer pricing does not exempt: that regime exempts the taxpayer from certain prohibitions on deductions and limitations on costs and expenses between related parties, but article 124 provides for no exception. Complying with the arm's length principle does not release the taxpayer from applying withholding.
- Other items: according to the case law cited in the ruling, payments to the head office for items other than administration or management are governed by articles 121 and 122 of the Tax Code, which require, among other conditions, withholding when the amount paid constitutes taxable income in Colombia.
Points that may interest you
- Review your contracts and keep the deliverables
- Each intercompany contract should describe the services and the deliverable in which each one materializes, and a file of those deliverables should be kept for each tax year, with an official translation when they are in another language.
- Verify withholding before deducting payments to the head office
- Payments to the head office or office abroad for administration or management are deductible only if withholding tax was applied. Complying with the transfer pricing regime does not replace this requirement.
- Document how the payment is allocated among the services
- If the payment to the related party compensates several services or the use of personnel abroad, you should keep the support showing how its value is allocated to each service. In the absence of that evidence, the Chamber upheld the figure set by the DIAN, even though the company argued that it included items that had not been challenged.
- Raise all arguments from the administrative stage
- The Chamber did not examine matters that were not raised in due time, such as the double taxation treaty with Chile, which was not invoked in the administrative proceedings, the complaint or the appeal, or the concept of shared cost centers.
- Keep the inaccuracy penalty in mind
- The disallowance of the deduction came with the inaccuracy penalty, which arises from the mere inclusion of improper deductions. For a difference of criteria to exempt the taxpayer from the penalty, it must be explained why the interpretation adopted was reasonable; merely invoking it is not enough.
- Support the expense with an electronic support document and accrue it in the correct period
- In addition to the requirements analyzed in the ruling, payments to foreign suppliers that do not issue electronic invoices in Colombia must be supported with the support document for acquisitions made from persons not required to invoice, generated and transmitted to the DIAN. The expense must be accrued in the tax year to which the service corresponds, and withholding tax must be applied at that time, which arises upon payment or accrual, whichever occurs first.
We are here to help
We remain available for any questions or, should you consider it appropriate, to review specific cases requiring our assistance.
Do you need to review a specific case?